Default Looms.

            Government deficits are covered by borrowing.  The government issues I.O.U.s in the form of Treasury bonds and other paper.  The borrowing gets added to the existing government debt.  The interest paid on that debt then becomes a current government expenditure.  It’s the same as paying for the Department of Defense or Social Security or air-traffic control. For may decades, the “Big Three” of US government outlays has been Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, and Defense.  (Together they accounted for about two-thirds of all federal spending.) 

            Then came Covid and shut-downs that threatened the economy.  Government, under both the Trump and Biden administrations, stepped up to the plate (or trough, if you’re a Paleo-Finance person).  Vast sums were paid out to “stimulate” the economy.  The total national debt now stands at more than $36 trillion. 

Inflation followed during the Biden administration.  Administration spokespeople down-played the price rises as long as they could.  Eventually, an election loomed.  The enraging effect on consumers and borrowers became too great to ignore.  The Federal Reserve Bank raised interest rates to choke off the inflation before it became really serious. 

            One effect (but not the only one) came in the borrowing costs paid by the government to entice lenders.  In 2024, interest payments by the federal government reached $881 billion.  Interest on the debt rudely shouldered its way past Defense as the third largest government expenditure.[1]  “But Wait!  There’s More!”  President Trump’s “Bigly Beautiful [Budget] Bill” has been projected to add $3 trillion to the debt by 2035.  Then the effect of tariffs on the economy is uncertain.  Economists expect the levies on imports to push up prices and slow the economy.  That would generate less revenue, perhaps less than the income from the tariffs. 

            Panicky warnings appeared in the media.  At some point, there could be a flight from US Treasuries by investors (including foreign governments that hold dollars) who doubt the value of promises to pay at least the interest.  The Federal Reserve Bank would have to raise interest rates much higher to rent the money to cover the interest on the debt or to finance current deficits.  Furthermore, government borrowing could crowd-out private sector borrowers who want the money to invest in productive activities.  That would drag on the economy, to put it mildly. 

            Is there a way out of this dilemma?  Yes.  It will require acting on both sides of the problem.  On the one hand, it means tax increases.  On the other hand, it means spending cuts. 

            Tax who and by how much?  The net worth (assets, not income) of the five richest Americans comes to about $1 trillion.[2]  The net worth of the next ten comes to about $1.1 trillion.  But income is what the government mostly taxes.  That’s much less than net worth. 

            Cut what and by how much?  To go where the money is, it means cutting Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, Defense, and Interest on the debt. 

            Both taxation and spending cuts will have to reach pretty far down into the ranks of the American middle class.  It will be hard to find politicians to vote for that.  The alternative is for ordinary American to suddenly abandon their “put it on the credit card” approach to citizenship.  Won’t happen.  Default looms.  After that, the International Monetary Fund will impose reforms. 


[1] “National debt: Why Congress no longer cares,” The Week, 6 June 2025, p. 17. 

[2] List of wealthiest Americans by net worth – Wikipedia 

Default Setting.

I’m not sure that History weighs on us, but Memory certainly does.[1]  For example, inflation and deflation are subjects of learning and memory for those who experience them.  Deflation (falling prices) plagued American borrowers and benefitted American lenders in the last quarter of the 19th Century.  People looked at inflation (rising prices) with longing or loathing.  If you were, say, 64 in 1934, then you were born in 1870.[2]  Growing up, you would probably have heard about reams of paper money printed without any fixed relationship to gold in order to finance your particular country’s search for victory in the Civil War.  As an adult, you would have read with exultation or dread, depending on your social class, William Jennings Bryan’s “Cross of Gold” speech and the Populist calls for the free coinage of silver at a ratio of 16:1.  That is, you would have been familiar with inflation as a good thing (for debtors) or a bad thing (for creditors), rather than as just a normal thing.  In the wake of the election of 1896, a conservative victory, Congress enacted American adhesion to the gold standard.  However, that was just Congress, a bunch of gutless poltroons (why else would you bribe them?) who might change their minds with the wind.  As a result, many lenders inserted “gold clauses” in contracts.  These obligated borrowers to repay in gold coins of “present weight and fineness” or in paper of equivalent value.  Basically, “gold clauses” were inflation-proofing insisted upon by lenders.  They applied to various contracts, but especially to bonds—government and corporate IOUs.

OK, skip ahead to the Great Depression of the 1930s.  Taking the leadership of a country sunk in the slough of despond, Franklin D. Roosevelt opted for inflation over deflation.  He severed the United States from the Gold Standard, which kept currencies fixed at specific rates of exchange, and then revalued the dollar.  This allowed Roosevelt to “raise” the price of gold held by the United States and print more dollars to accommodate its higher price.  The “price” of gold rose from about $21/ounce to $35/ounce.  So, by about two-thirds.  This inflated prices and devalued debts.  Great!  For anyone who had debts not inflation-proofed.

At this point, Roosevelt’s policy slammed into the “gold clauses” on many bonds.  Because of the two-thirds rise in the price of gold, debtors had to pay lenders about two-thirds more than they had borrowed.  One of those debtors was the United States government, which owed about $20 billion in gold-clause bonds.[3]  In 1935, the Supreme Court—in the “gold clause cases:–held that the government could abrogate public and private gold clauses.  That is, the U.S. government is not obligated to pay its debts and it did not pay them in this case.

Still, it is a commonplace that the United States has never defaulted on its debts.  That reassuring belief keeps people buying Treasury bonds when the deficit and national debt keep growing to extraordinary levels.  Except, maybe Bill Gross when he was at PIMCO.[4]

[1] That’s probably why “we” never learn from the past, but individuals often do learn from the past.  There is no way to transmit the acquired knowledge.  They why study History at all?  Because smart people will be among the few who learn lessons and for everyone else, it’s pretty entertaining.

[2] Sebastian Edwards, American Default: The Untold Story of FDR, the Supreme Court, and the Battle over Gold (2018).

[3] Worth about $380 billion in 2018 dollars.

[4] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/03/pimcos-gross-asks-who-will-buy-treasuries-when-the-fed-doesnt/72276/ ; https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/05/bill-gross-on-deficits-and-the-fed/238682/