Netanyahu.

            Benjamin Netanyahu was born with the State of Israel.  He was born in Tel Aviv in 1949, the son of the brilliant Revisionist Zionist fanatic Benzion Netanyahu.  He spent much of his youth in the United States,[1] then returned to Israel for military service.  No shirker he: Netanyahu spent five years in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), much of it in combat with the special forces.[2]  Then back to the United States to pursue a degree in Architecture at M.I.T.[3]  He eventually received the BA, plus an MA in Management.[4] 

            Netanyahu made a rapid ascent in politics.  One way and another, he had a lot of connections in Israel.  In 1984, those connections, brains, a familiarity with the United States, and a really good war record led to his appointment as Israel’s representative to the United Nations.  Back in the US, he gave good interview to television reporters.  In 1988 he entered parliament (the Knesset); in 1993 he won the leadership of the Likud party; in 1996 he became prime minister.  In 1999, voters gave Likud, and Netanyahu with it, the heave. 

            Since then, Netanyahu’s career has been linked to Gaza and the West Bank.  He got a cabinet position when Likud regained a majority, then, in 2005, resigned when Ariel Sharon ordered an end to the occupation of Gaza.  Hamas soon evicted the Palestinian Authority from Gaza, creating a radical anti-Israel and pro-Iran bastion on the border.  In 2009, as Israeli voters confronted these harsh new conditions, Netanyahu returned as Prime Minister.  Since then, he has campaigned for a regional alliance with Sunni Arab states to contain (at the least) Iran.  At the same time, however, he has had to juggle the rivalry between the Palestinian Authority (governing the West Bank) and Hamas.  In the case of Hamas, he has allowed Qatar to send millions of dollars in aid to Gaza.  He’s also had to bargain with the tiny, far-right parties who make his parliamentary majority possible.  This has forced (or allowed) him to permit expanding settlements in Arab territory on the West Bank.  He had a lot of irons in the fire. 

            Perhaps his skill at managing those irons made him complacent.  Iran had armed and advised clients all around Israel’s borders.  Hamas in Gaza, but also Hezbollah in Lebanon,[5] and the Assad regime in Syria, and the Houthis in Yemen.  In any event, on 7 October 2023 Hamas launched a devastating surprise attack that killed 1,200 Israelis and captured a couple hundred others before the Hamas troops scuttled back into Gaza.  There they hid among the Palestinian civilians in anticipation of an Israeli counter-attack.  They may also have expected Netanyahu to have been tossed out of power after this disaster.  They may have expected Hezbollah and even Iran to have joined in the war.  But Netanyahu refused to resign.   He was inventive, ruthless, and brave as a special forces soldier.  Now he’s that again.  He held onto power, while launching a “savage war of peace” against Hamas, then Hezbollah, and then Iran. 

            Now Gaza lies in ruins with scores of thousands dead.  The architect, the special forces soldier, and—for the moment—the dominant force in the Middle East. 


[1] He didn’t much like the American culture of the 1960s.  It was fun at the time, but he may have a point.  He doesn’t think much of recent American presidents.  Who would: three adolescents, a dotard, and a feral child. 

[2] So, no bone spurs, no asthma, no “politically viable,” no Air National Guard.  More like JFK and Bob Kerry. 

[3] Look at the realities, develop a vision, work to make it real. 

[4] His studies were interrupted by a return to the IDF during the 1973 war.  Must have been interesting sharing a dorm room with him.   

[5] To the point that the country might better be called Hezbollanon. 

The Last War of Netanyahu.

            In less than a week it will be the twenty-third anniversary of 9/11.  The memory of that attack by terrorists seems to be turning to empty tradition with the passage of time.  Yet, 9/11 sparked the “Forever Wars” (only recently concluded) and the “USA Patriot Act,” and some really bad country music.  One of the most remarkable things is how totally Americans have lost understanding of how a democracy may react to being blind-sided by “evil doers.” 

Writing on 2 August 2024, WSJ foreign affairs columnist Walter Russell Mead saw Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu successfully threading the needle.[1]  Mead believes that in the waning days of the Biden administration, its foreign policy team[2] hopes to prevent an expanded war in the Middle East.  Such a war would encompass a full-scale Hezbollah-Israel war and even war between Israel and Iran.  They fear that the United States would be drawn into such a conflict.  So, they are pushing hard for a cease-fire in Gaza and urging restraint on Israel. 

Mead also believes that Hamas, Turkey, and Iran hope to “bamboozle” the Biden administration into supporting a peace process that runs from a cease-fire to the creation of a Palestinian state in all but name, one in which Hamas holds the real power.  This effort might succeed because the “two-state solution” remains the goal of the Biden foreign policy team. 

            Recently, Israeli forces have killed Mohammed Deif (Hamas military commander); Fuad Shakr (Hezbollah military commander); and Ismail Haniyeh[3] (Hamas political leader).  These attacks threaten to stall efforts at a cease-fire in Gaza and to bring on the larger war with Iran.  Hence, Biden’s people are frustrated (or perhaps furious) with the actions of Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu.  Mead sees these killings as reassuring the Israeli public, which generally hates Hamas and Hezbollah.  The killings also give notice to the Gulf states that Israel remains a tough and skillful opponent.  The Gulf states are caught between Arab solidarity and a fear of Iran.  Signs of Israel buckling at the knees might send them scurrying to make nice with Iran.  The killings may have a deterrent effect. 

            Striking enemies when they rear their head may not be enough to bring Israel security over the long run.  Kamala Harris has no long-standing ties to Israel comparable to those which have long influenced the Democratic party.  The gory war to the knife in Gaza has appalled many people.  The division between supporters and critics of Israel now runs through the Democratic party.  A President Harris might prefer to hold Israel at arm’s length going forward.  With Iran close to breaking through to making nuclear weapons, a Harris administration might want to put all its efforts into achieving a last-minute return to the Obama administration’s agreement with Iran. 

            Mead wrote all this a month before Hamas killed six Israeli prisoners to prevent their rescue by Israeli troops.  The explosion of fury in a large part of Israel’s public has challenged Netanyahu’s policy and tenuous grip on power.  He refuses—so far–to give in.  His campaign to destroy Hamas grinds forward.  It brings Israeli troops ever closer to the remaining prisoners.  There may be more executions to come.  If so, there will be more massive demonstrations in the streets of Tel Aviv.  Perhaps this will be the final crisis for Netanyahu.  But not for Israel. 


[1] Walter Russell Mead, “Israel Brings Deterrence Back to the War on Terror,” WSJ, 2 August 2024. 

[2] Secretary of State Antony Blinken, National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan, CIA Director William Burns. 

[3] Mohammed Deif – Wikipedia; Fuad Shukr – WikipediaIsmail Haniyeh – Wikipedia